Should we treat transgenders as mentally ill?

May 2015
42
11
Chicago, Illinois
I think we have to do it. I'm so tired of that transgender propaganda. There is no such thing as a 'transgender' person. A transgender is just a pervert with fake tits and completely ruined health. Why do we pretend that transgenders really exist? Okay, I can understand when an adult person put breast implants but when a crook doctor tells a kid needs to make a 'transition' it's just too much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Jul 2008
19,064
12,953
Virginia Beach, VA
I think we have to do it. I'm so tired of that transgender propaganda. There is no such thing as a 'transgender' person. A transgender is just a pervert with fake tits and completely ruined health. Why do we pretend that transgenders really exist? Okay, I can understand when an adult person put breast implants but when a crook doctor tells a kid needs to make a 'transition' it's just too much.
And your psychology degree is from.....?
 
Jun 2015
1,881
1,386
Minnesota
I think we have to do it. I'm so tired of that transgender propaganda. There is no such thing as a 'transgender' person. A transgender is just a pervert with fake tits and completely ruined health. Why do we pretend that transgenders really exist? Okay, I can understand when an adult person put breast implants but when a crook doctor tells a kid needs to make a 'transition' it's just too much.
Wow! You seem either very phobic or very angry, and maybe a little off balance. Maybe you should talk to a counselor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Nov 2012
22,986
5,052
Gamma Solaris
Isn't getting their sexual status changed by an operation and hormone therapy treating mental illness??? Sure looks that way...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
Apr 2013
24,581
11,618
The Milky Way
It treats nothing. The suicide rates amongst these people post operative is extremely high.

The doctors performing such surgery are butchers, not to the level of Planed Parenthood, but butchers nonetheless. He is still a he, she is still a she. DNA says so. Pandering is not treatment.


 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Feb 2014
12,580
7,845
nunya
The suicide rate of transgender people is way high and the percentage of them working in sex trades is high. I think there is merit to questioning the mental health of someone who wants to have a sex change procedure. I am pretty sure the pc police wont allow that conversation though. So, even if there is a diminished mental capacity behind being transgender, it wont be dealt with. Political correctness before reason
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Jun 2015
1,881
1,386
Minnesota
The suicide rate of transgender people is way high and the percentage of them working in sex trades is high. I think there is merit to questioning the mental health of someone who wants to have a sex change procedure. I am pretty sure the pc police wont allow that conversation though. So, even if there is a diminished mental capacity behind being transgender, it wont be dealt with. Political correctness before reason
The thing about adult mental health care in the U.S. is that, unless someone is presenting a very real and immediate danger to others or to themselves, they cannot be treated without consent.
 
Dec 2006
26,829
12,082
New Haven, CT
I think we have to do it. I'm so tired of that transgender propaganda. There is no such thing as a 'transgender' person. A transgender is just a pervert with fake tits and completely ruined health. Why do we pretend that transgenders really exist? Okay, I can understand when an adult person put breast implants but when a crook doctor tells a kid needs to make a 'transition' it's just too much.
Would you present us with your medical credentials before making medical diagnosis on patients whom you have never seen?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Aug 2014
1,318
904
Earth
I am a white male and I have decided that was born the wrong color and I want to be black. I color my skin (if possible, I don't think it is), get an artificial hair transplant, wear different clothes, "speak black", get a black girlfriend and I "identify" with being black.

Will blacks accept me? No. They would tell me that I am an idiot white boy trying to adapt to their culture, I don't belong, and I might get my ass beat. Just saying. Some might tell me truthfully that I might have a mental problem that needs to be resolved.

Transgenderism is a mental illness. It causes people to to be comfortable with their own gender and bodies, and desire to be the other sex. But this is simply impossible. There is something deep rooted inside the mind of people like Jenner and Chaz/Chastity Bono that they have gone through such drastic measures. It is not normal, not right, and just "accepting" it really does more harm than good.

Jenner will never be female, and has absolutely no right to pawn HIMSELF as one. He has never had a period (this is why I thank Allah he made me male) never had to go through a lot of struggles women have to go through. It is hard to be a woman, to have to wear makeup, a bra, the changing of the body as a child, to be sexually chased by oversexed men. Again, I am too lazy to be female and not man enough to be one.

What is really bad are parents of children who identify their children as "transgender", as in little kindergarten kids. One (and I will look this up) is a couple who had a girl who was deaf and could not speak. The deafness was repairable someway, and supposedly one of the first thing that came out of this young girl's mouth was that she is a boy and not a girl, and do not refer me as a girl. And the parents accepted this, so much so that they cart the kid around to homosexual conferences preaching "tolerance". What is going to happen when this "boy" is 12 and grows breasts and has a period? What then, remove the uterus? Should HER parents have the right to do this? Or is possibly a CHILD PSYCHOLOGIST in order?

It's a mental illness.